YouTube's copyright system is broken

118 683
Mumbo Jumbo
Mumbo Jumbo - 3 months ago
UPDATE (as taken from my twitter)

Things are a bit muddy.
- I do have written permission from the artist to use the claimed song.
- However; the song uses a sample that has been picked up by Warners content ID bot. So I am being claimed for a sample, not the song.

I'm still hoping we can resolve this.
And take this as a lesson from me:
Not only should you ensure you have complete rights to the music you are using for your videos, but also ensure that you ask about any samples that have been used. Otherwise you could end up in this situation (And you wouldn't want that).
Will do a video on Tuesday explaining. I am taking a day off tomorrow!
Nolan Barclay
Nolan Barclay - 4 hours ago found this jem!! take it and see what you can do!!
ZeroDay Boi
ZeroDay Boi - Day ago
People get those claims even without the song, like no sound what so ever and again you get claimed. The RUvideos system is trash and it always have been trash
Carol Pintilie
Carol Pintilie - 7 days ago
basically fuck youtube's copyright system at the moment
Spencer Lloyd
Spencer Lloyd - 7 days ago
Mumbo you are my favourite RUvideosr ever
The cool Is all in m
The cool Is all in m - 31 minute ago
Alan S
Alan S - 6 hours ago
Definitely not expect you actually don't have mustache.
Campbell Jackson
Campbell Jackson - 9 hours ago
Where’s your moustache?
GeneralAlexander - 10 hours ago
hows the situation now
jake gowan
jake gowan - 11 hours ago
*This video's revenue is now property of Warner Chappell, if you wish to subtract this claim please go to the following site*

There is no site
GREENWOLF 1337 - 23 hours ago
There's a YouTube counter issue to each solution.
Dispute a claim? Unscrupulous claimant decides your fate.
Try to get traction? Botting.
Legal action? Evasion.
There's no escape.
Izzy ___
Izzy ___ - Day ago
Warner Chappel wish they could build that ridiculous piston house.
E. Blade
E. Blade - Day ago
That's bull man.
Francesca Jones
Francesca Jones - Day ago
Some of the videos claimed were completely random.
Awesome man troll #10
You should dive in with a redstone torch and block in hand to check out where it all went wrong
Jelly cubes guy
Jelly cubes guy - Day ago
Popular YouTuber: creates video
Corporations: It'S fReE rEaL EsTaTe
Jacob Collis
Jacob Collis - Day ago
And the fact that they get to get keep the revenue even if it is a false claim Jesus.
GlitchyYoshi 546
GlitchyYoshi 546 - Day ago
Oh great. The last thing I want is for YouTube's moderation system to be like roblox's moderation system. (Which is very bad)
Ananth Venuturupalle
Ananth Venuturupalle - 2 days ago
This just isnt fair . . .
Phoach - 2 days ago
Upload to LBRY along side YouTube so they get competition
Cepha - 2 days ago
C418 music plays in the background when u play minecraft
Warner Chappell: hippity hoppity your livelihood is now my property
CarlAnimates - 2 days ago
I just got here from Ruben sim
Seth Smiles
Seth Smiles - 2 days ago
Good the thumbnail says “Warner chappell” an extra l
Hendrik de Boer
Hendrik de Boer - 2 days ago
Imposter! You even don't have a mustache
Josefhate - 2 days ago
Youtube copyright system: This random guy OWNS that. You're trying to apeal the copyright strike? He said, "I'm right you're wrong lol."
Sativa B
Sativa B - 2 days ago
My Life Is a lie you dont have a mustache..
Freedbot - 3 days ago
Nothing will ever come of this issue that has spanned several years until content creators actually do come together and sue. Youtube has come under quite a bit of pressure to be sure thanks to the terrors of the ad-pocalypse, but they are certainly not faultless. This is a very large economy built on a shaky foundation. As such, youtube themselves will have to be sued as well as the worst offenders. This isn't even about fair use anymore, this is flagrant malicious abuse of livelihood over the desire to make an unearned buck through threats.
Mckenzie Welsh
Mckenzie Welsh - 3 days ago
You remind me of James cordon
Wun Foe
Wun Foe - 3 days ago
So you can use others music forever without paying them....? Publishing is a business.
Dorian - 3 days ago
The sellout/commie side of YouTube. Guilty until proven innocent. Shady busyness.
Daniel Moolman
Daniel Moolman - 3 days ago
Warner Chappel seems to claim everything. Honestly they should face serious legal penalties, and a full dissolve of their company if they don’t abide.
icy dino
icy dino - 4 days ago
this is why the most disliked video on Youtube is by Youtube
מקסים מיכאלסון
I hate youtube
Christian Poethke
Christian Poethke - 4 days ago
Use a redstone blocker Mumbo
Fyrenyde - 4 days ago
Go on Twitter and everywhere you can and say that you're taking legal action against them and you're reviewing your options. J guy named Danny gonzolez did this and they stopped copyrighting him
Fyrenyde - 4 days ago
I genuinely hope that if there's a hell, then the people that do this to Youtubers that have done nothing wrong are burning in their own personal hell
pickle rick
pickle rick - 4 days ago
Why the fuck do you not have a mustache
CBrickProduction's - 5 days ago
YouTube is going to get rid of there creators if they're not careful
UltraOmnivore - 5 days ago
firefly night
firefly night - 5 days ago
*this video has been copyright claimed*
Edgard Lee Reyes
Edgard Lee Reyes - 5 days ago
Just do a new channel, ur fans will never let u down ......... no mustache (☉。☉)!
i bet warner chappel can't build a witch farm
celloc - 5 days ago
why is your house so nice aaaa
Tyler Clubb
Tyler Clubb - 5 days ago
This is totally whack. I’m glad someone’s finally explaining it because many YouTubers have mentioned it but not explained it.
Spenser - 5 days ago
This really sucks. They need to fix the system for this and I hope you can figure it out. Sorry about this mate.
legion999 - 5 days ago can make false claims willy-nilly, but "false" disputes are a big deal with punitive consequences? Disgusting.
Cree price
Cree price - 5 days ago
FUCK THAT MAN! Seriously dude, your such a nice guy who is genuinely a creator on youtube! take it to court mumbo! Take it to court!
Kyler Withrow
Kyler Withrow - 5 days ago
Fuck YouTube they don’t care
Renso Daniel Del Castillo Vega
You should check the case of CNN Chile against LuisitoComunica
Random Memes Weekly
Random Memes Weekly - 5 days ago
cycodude boi
cycodude boi - 5 days ago
Dear Mumbo Jumbo your video: YouTube's copyright system is broken, contains air, this has been claimed by UMG for breathing similar air to the songwriters in our company
AshtonIsaiah Caldwell
AshtonIsaiah Caldwell - 5 days ago
This is also happening to JT from a guy named enes batur
boulderbash19700209 - 6 days ago
Still don't believe EU article 13 will kill the internet?
Muhammad Fadhilah
Muhammad Fadhilah - 6 days ago
and don't worry.. I've made a video too and they also tell that my own voice is their song... but it's not even a song.
Link The Fox
Link The Fox - 6 days ago
Put up a lawsuit with Warner Chapel
Muhammad Fadhilah
Muhammad Fadhilah - 6 days ago
where's your moustache?
The Rockstar Gamer
The Rockstar Gamer - 6 days ago
“Innocent until proven guilty”
The entire globe:
:D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D
Xealz - 6 days ago
Kill those bastards
Nice Shoes
Nice Shoes - 6 days ago
You look like jamie oliver
Kuba Czupyt
Kuba Czupyt - 6 days ago
A gaming channel called “Teo” had the exact same situation (same company, same deal with his outro music) about a week ago, he managed to have the claims removed.
:/ - 6 days ago
Mumbo's Legal Borrowed Music: *Breathes*
-InfStudios- - 6 days ago
Just Realized Logdotzip Liked This.
The Savage Method
The Savage Method - 6 days ago
Most importantly this has been a growing problem with youtube. Over the last year or so I've seen many videos of my favorite channels face similar problems. The new algorithms used are hurting content creators and forcing censorship of different channels. On a side not Mumbo you really should have worn a stash I mean its kinda your thing. It was kinda disappointing you didnt at least wear a fake stash. I know this is a serious topic that effects your livelihood but by staying in character I believe that your important message would have reached even further. Just my honest opinion. Honestly I think its time someone replaced youtube and their new gestapo rules. On the flip side maybe its time to branch out a little to secure your much needed paycheck.
DaniloKING 2
DaniloKING 2 - 6 days ago
Ok this is what I call communism
ComicalOrange - 6 days ago
YouTube needs several different HQ's, so this shit is easier to sort out.
Ignacio Sánchez
Ignacio Sánchez - 6 days ago
Make a redstone contraption to reclaim the videos
Ali Razi
Ali Razi - 6 days ago
We should all just boycott you tube until they fix this shit do u know if minecraft community gaming community and nine year old army just boycott youtube for a single week how much revenue they'll lose
Foxstrike Computing
Foxstrike Computing - 6 days ago
Don’t worry, my channel got taken down for someone Spanish getting into my account. I had to email them for months to get it back! Darn hackers!
LossGaming - 6 days ago
Yeah sorry, I own this video now.
daneeko - 6 days ago
its absolutely fine for companies to have bots automatically copyright claim videos for the smallest reasons, and then not get punished for it
adds reclame
adds reclame - 6 days ago
Make a company account and claim your own videos
PhilippeAquilaniAndre - 6 days ago
I agree one video of mine got Copyright claim even tho I USED COPYRIGHT FREE SONGS ON THAT DAMN VIDEO!!!
Mathu-Andrew Budge
Mathu-Andrew Budge - 7 days ago
welp, i'm off to copyright claim all of warner bros videos.
PHOTON - 7 days ago
talking about losing his million-dollar penthouse.
Though ya, still...fuck warner chappell
Luke Gabriel Balgan
Luke Gabriel Balgan - 7 days ago
I can only imagine when the comment section gets copyright-claimed. Among the several millions of comments, perhaps billions even, the chance that no two comments are similar is basically 0. And if the whole 3 strikes you're out thing extends to taking down the account altogether, all accounts that currently exist are 100% screwed. Let's hope that doesn't happen.
Reidsplosion 214
Reidsplosion 214 - 7 days ago
either UMG or Warner.
MulletEagle - 7 days ago

Where's your mustache?
JoshIsSarcastic - 7 days ago
This is what exactly what happened to Pyrocinical
Soup Bear
Soup Bear - 7 days ago
The system is so broken, like the people that claim videos should actually show proof that they have the rights to claim a video, YouTube should actually watch over these things since they can have bad outcomes for a channel but no YouTube is just lazy
Bernie Sanders
Bernie Sanders - 7 days ago
They should give copyright strikes to those who create false claims
Reazet - 7 days ago
YouTube doesn't care about who made what, best example is famous musician TheFatRat. His music is being taken down for just being a free source. Silent clips can be taken down for music copyright violation and be happy that your channel is still up, I had a rdm video on a rdm channel. The channel is gone. With no influence you are fucked on YouTube.
IsaacC 123
IsaacC 123 - 7 days ago
Mariano Lucas
Mariano Lucas - 7 days ago
I guess we must refer to them as Whiner Chappell, I mean, that's their real name right?
Next videos